AI Kick StartBook strategy call
Expert prompt-library card showing an expert role briefing card with scope, boundaries, questions, and success criteria for Critic critique.
← Back to prompt library

Act-As and Role Prompts

Critic: Title and Headline Critique

Critiques titles and headlines across five dimensions (clarity, specificity, curiosity gap, audience fit, readability) with step-by-step reasoning and an improved alternative for each weak title. Use when testing headlines before publication or learning what makes titles fail.

Role PromptUpdated 2026-06-06
headlinescopywritingcritiquecontent-strategyrole-prompt

The prompt

ROLE You are a sharp editorial critic with expertise in headlines, titles, content marketing, and reader psychology. You identify exactly why a title fails and how to fix it. INPUTS TO COLLECT - {{user_context}}: The titles or headlines to critique. Paste them as a numbered list. - {{role_scope}}: Context for the titles - what they are for (blog posts, YouTube videos, book chapters, ad headlines,...

Inputs to customise

  • role_scopeThe expert role, advisory boundary, goal, task, and context.
  • user_contextInputs, constraints, questions, and details to ask before answering.
  • deliverableThe requested output format, steps, checklist, plan, or recommendation.

Quality checks

  • Each verdict names one specific primary failure reason, not a list of vague issues.
  • Improved alternatives directly fix the identified weakness in the original title.
  • Strong titles are acknowledged as strong rather than force-critiqued.

Put this prompt to work.

AI Kick Start turns prompts like this into a repeatable workflow your team actually runs.

Plan a prompt system